ClubHub

For the people who run clubs

Menu

By Wade Hart · 4 min read · First added 7 Oct 2026

Don't make good volunteers work harder because of bad members

Good volunteers should not do more complicated work for the sake of bad members. Three questions to ask about any rule, form or approval step in your club.

Ink drawing of a man in a sun hat walking away from a desk with a tall pile of forms, carrying a croquet mallet toward a hoop on the lawn.

CAQ's position: good volunteers should not do more complicated work because of a few bad members.

On myCroquet, a member's handicap change now goes through straight away. The captain steps in only to reverse a wrong change.

That removes work for 40 or more volunteers.

Three questions can test any club rule, form or sign-off.

This is for committee members, captains, secretaries and treasurers who want fewer forms and sign-offs at their club.

How clubs do it

  1. Who does this make work for? One volunteer, or several, every week?
  2. Who is this work serving? Does it help most members, or is it there only because of a worry about one or two bad members? Is it needed at all?
  3. Can it be put back if it goes wrong? A mistake that is easy to fix or undo is a small worry.

These are the three questions CAQ suggests asking of any rule, form or sign-off.

What happened with the handicap card

When the handicap card was tested on 5 October 2026, a member could change their own index in myCroquet, but a big change (more than 50 points) waited for the club captain to approve it. Until then the player's handicap was stuck.

That delay hurt honest players, not cheats. It also gave the captain extra work because of a rare cheat.

The live version swaps the order. A big change goes through straight away, and the captain steps in only if a change needs to be reversed.

If one player misuses it, the plan is to warn them first. If it keeps happening, self-editing is paused for that one player and switched back on when things are right. Everyone else carries on. You can read the full story in The handicap card is live on myCroquet.

Why CAQ thinks this way

This is CAQ's Keep it Simple Ideal: "Outcomes over complexity. Do less admin and play more croquet." Adding volunteer work and harder systems for the sake of the worst members is a poor use of people's time.

The same thinking guides other parts of myCroquet. CAQ's rule for approval steps in the calendar is to default to trust: a review is there to catch bad actions, not to slow down people acting in good faith.

Where this comes from

  1. ClubHub, The handicap card is live on myCroquet: the handicap card change
  2. CAQ's four Ideals: Keep it Simple

Back to Your committee and your rules

Comments

Ask a question or tell us what worked at your club. Replies show under your comment.